@prefix adms: <http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#> .
@prefix category: <http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap/codelist/category/> .
@prefix contenttype: <http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap/codelist/content-type/> .
@prefix dcat: <http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat#> .
@prefix dct: <http://purl.org/dc/terms/> .
@prefix eira: <http://data.europa.eu/dr8/> .
@prefix elap: <http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap/> .
@prefix foaf: <http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/> .
@prefix influence: <http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap/codelist/influence/> .
@prefix ioplayer: <http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap/codelist/iop-layer/> .
@prefix org: <http://www.w3.org/ns/org#> .
@prefix pagovernance: <http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap/codelist/pa-governance/> .
@prefix xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#> .

<http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap> a dcat:Catalog ;
    elap:principle elap:ICT-management-from-cradle-to-grave,
        elap:accessibility,
        elap:administrative-simplification,
        elap:best-fit-implementation-orientation,
        elap:code-of-ethics-compliance,
        elap:composability,
        elap:conformance-chain,
        elap:convergence-on-public-policy-goals-attainment,
        elap:cost-efficiency,
        elap:digital-first-leave-no-one-behind,
        elap:digital-partnership,
        elap:digital-resilience,
        elap:digital-sovereignty,
        elap:eu-legislation-compliance,
        elap:findability,
        elap:integrated-horizontal-user-experience,
        elap:interoperability,
        elap:level-playing-field,
        elap:loose-coupling,
        elap:maintainability,
        elap:measurability,
        elap:multilingualism,
        elap:openness,
        elap:portability,
        elap:preservation-of-information,
        elap:privacy,
        elap:proactiveness,
        elap:proportionality,
        elap:reference-architecture,
        elap:reuse-before-buy-before-build,
        elap:scalability,
        elap:security-by-design,
        elap:separation-of-concerns,
        elap:service-orientation,
        elap:social-participation,
        elap:solution-fit,
        elap:subsidiarity,
        elap:technology-neutrality,
        elap:transparency,
        elap:trust,
        elap:uncertainty-management,
        elap:use-of-standards,
        elap:user-centricity ;
    dct:issued "2026-11-30"^^xsd:date ;
    dct:license <http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/licence/EUPL_1_2> ;
    dct:publisher [ a foaf:Organization ;
            org:subOrganizationOf <http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body/DIGIT> ;
            foaf:name "CAMSS Team, DIGIT B2"@en ] ;
    dct:title "European Library of Architecture Principles (ELAP)"@en ;
    adms:versionNotes """4--1 Principle removal: Confidentiality principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--2 Principle removal: Environmental sustainability principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--3 Principle removal: EU localisation framework compliance principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--4 Principle removal: Evidence based public policy principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--5 Principle removal: Innovation principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--6 Principle removal: Integrity principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--7 Principle removal: Non repudiation principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--8 Principle removal: Once only principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--9 Principle removal: Operational excellence principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--10 Principle removal: Public value maximisation principle has been removed in ELAP v4.0.0
4--11 Principle update: User-centricity and Reuse, before buy, before build principles have been modified in order to gather information relative to the Once only principle.
4--12 Principle update: Security by design principle has been modified in order to gather information relative to the Confidentiality, Integrity, and Non repudiation principles.
4--13 Principle update: Cost efficiency principle has been modified in order to gather information relative to the Operational excellence and Accountability principles.
4--16 "ABB Association" category updated: The ABB associations have been updated in ELAP v4.0.0. The ABBs previously linked to the merged or removed principles are now associated with the principles that absorbed them, so the current principles cover both their original ABBs and those inherited.
4--17 "IoP Layer" category updated: The IoP layers have been updated in ELAP v4.0.0. The IoP layers previously assigned to the merged or removed principles are now assigned to the principles that absorbed them, so the current principles cover both their original layers and those inherited."""@en ;
    dcat:themeTaxonomy <http://data.europa.eu/2sa/elap/codelist/iop-layer> ;
    dcat:version "4.0.0" .

elap:ICT-management-from-cradle-to-grave a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "How the EU wants to achieve a circular economy by 2050."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications """When implementing and retiring elements related to the provision of digital public services, public administrations shall include and create policies that ensure the lifecycle of infrastructures, applications services and equipment is considered and extended to ensure the minimum waste in terms of sustainability.

An example regarding this last topic is, for instance, the application of policies to ensure that no additional costs (economic, social and environmental) rise when renewing the computer fleet."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:nws ;
    elap:rationale "Public administrations are the first link in the chain and need to set an example for society and businesses by managing the entire life cycle of technology products. Therefore, when planning and designing public services, this aspect needs to be included from design and implementation to retirement. Such care for the full ICT life cycle comes at a critical stage for sustainable development, amplified by the excess use of resources (economic, natural, etc.). Considering this, public administrations need to establish and use relevant policies that help ensure and control sustainability at all levels."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "A full life cycle cost of ownership (including retirement costs) should form part of the business case."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/society/20210128STO96607/how-the-eu-wants-to-achieve-a-circular-economy-by-2050> ;
    dct:title "ICT management from cradle to grave"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:accessibility a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "This publication explores the broader economic and social benefits of accessibility, including how it supports social equity and reduces digital divides. It also discusses the importance of legal frameworks and standardised mechanisms."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:APIEnablersGrouping,
        eira:DataManagementEnablersGrouping,
        eira:InteroperableDigitalSolutionApplicationComponent,
        eira:UserExperienceManagementEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Accessibility, organisations must adopt standardised mechanisms. Public sector bodies must take necessary measures to make their electronic services perceivable, operable, understandable, and robust. This includes designing, constructing, maintaining, and updating digital services with accessibility principles and techniques in mind, ensuring that all citizens, regardless of their digital capabilities, can access and benefit from these services. Additionally, organisations should implement regular accessibility audits and user testing to identify and address any barriers. Training and awareness programs for staff are essential to embed accessibility considerations into the organisational culture. Legal and regulatory frameworks should be established and enforced to ensure compliance with accessibility standards, promoting a consistent and inclusive approach across all public services."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Implementing the principle of Accessibility when providing public services is crucial for promoting inclusivity and ensuring that all citizens can benefit from public services and data. Service accessibility ensures that public services are designed to be perceivable, operable, understandable, and robust, catering to the diverse needs of all citizens, including those with disabilities. By adhering to accessibility principles, public administrations can enhance user experience, foster trust, and ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. Accessibility also supports social equity by providing equal opportunities for all individuals to access information and services, thereby reducing digital divides and fostering a more inclusive society."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional ;
    elap:statement "Accessibility ensures that data, services, and solutions from public administrations are available and usable by all citizens, regardless of their capabilities, background, or disabilities, through standardised mechanisms."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/towards-a-framework-for-identifying-and-measuring-the-benefits-of-accessibility_9c674d70-en.html> ;
    dct:title "Accessibility"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:administrative-simplification a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "Simplify processes and use digital channels whenever appropriate for the delivery of European public services, to respond promptly and with high quality to users’ requests and reduce the administrative burden on public administrations, businesses and citizens."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:npm ;
    elap:rationale """Administrative simplification means, where possible, streamlining and simplifying administrative processes by improving them or eliminating anything that does not provide public value. Administrative simplification can help businesses and citizens to reduce the administrative burden of complying with EU legislation or national obligations.

Digitisation of public services should take place in accordance with the following concepts:

• digital-by-default, whenever appropriate, so that there is at least one digital channel available for accessing and using a given European public service;

• digital-first which means that priority is given to using public services via digital channels while applying the multi-channel delivery concept and the no-wrong-door policy, i.e. physical and digital channels co-exist."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Where possible, public administrations should seek to streamline and simplify their administrative processes by improving them or eliminating any that do not provide public value."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/administrative-simplification> ;
    dct:title "Administrative simplification"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:best-fit-implementation-orientation a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "EUR-Lex is your online gateway to EU Law. It provides the official and most comprehensive access to EU legal documents. It is available in all of the EU’s 24 official languages and is updated daily."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications """An assessment of the context is made prior to the implementation in order to determine the best focus.
The priority of the implementation activities is determined by the chosen focus.
Use mechanisms provided by the European Commission to plan and align the strategy with real needs. An example is IDPSIO, the IDPSIO (Interoperable Digital Public Services Implementation Orientation) Assessment Tool aims to support digital public service owners in deciding the approach to follow in order to implement their digital public services."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Experience shows that a focused approach is a critical success factor in the implementation of digital public services."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional ;
    elap:statement "The implementation of digital public services has a focus on integration, technology, governance or legal perspective, matching the administration's preference."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A52017DC0134> ;
    dct:title "Best fit implementation orientation"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:code-of-ethics-compliance a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Ombudsman is an independent and impartial body that holds the EU’s institutions and agencies to account, and promotes good administration. The Ombudsman helps people, businesses and organisations facing problems with the EU’s administration by investigating complaints about maladministration by EU institutions and bodies, but also by proactively looking into broader systemic issues."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "All initiatives and services must be aligned and compliant with a code of ethics. (Ad-hoc for the organisational, local, regional, national or at European Level)."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """A code of ethics is a written set of expectations that an organisation has for its employees to conduct business in an honest manner. Ethics are values and principles that govern behaviour or conduct.

Apart from legislation, the European foundational text "Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union" sets up the different terms and relevant aspects for the proper function of the European Union.

All public services provided by public administrations under the European Union need to be aligned and compliant with organisations' code of ethics, which should be aligned with national and European values."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance ;
    elap:statement "Code of ethics compliance refers to the expression of important values and standards that are also to be found in the law, but not only aspects related to legally-binding issues."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/speech/en/49379> ;
    dct:title "Code of ethics compliance"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational .

elap:composability a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The chapter \"The Pillars of Composability\" from Pro TBB illustrates how modular, interchangeable components in parallel programming enhance flexibility and scalability—core aspects of composability. This technical perspective aligns with the broader principle of composability in digital public services, where modular building blocks enable reuse, adaptability, and simplified system orchestration. Both contexts emphasise the value of designing systems that are robust, flexible, and easy to evolve."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Composability, organisations must adopt a modular approach to design and development, ensuring that each building block has a well-defined scope and set of responsibilities. Business processes should include clear guidelines for defining, documenting, and selecting building blocks. Technically, solutions must support modularity and interoperability, with components that can be easily integrated, replaced, or reconfigured. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to ensure that the composability principle is maintained throughout the lifecycle of the solution. Additionally, fostering a culture of innovation and collaboration is essential to encourage the development and reuse of modular building blocks. Training and capacity-building initiatives should be implemented to ensure that all stakeholders understand and can effectively apply the principle of composability."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Implementing the principle of Composability in digital public services and solutions is crucial for reducing complexity and enhancing flexibility. By dividing a solution into modular building blocks, each with clear boundaries and specific capabilities, organisations can address smaller, more manageable problems. This approach simplifies the selection process, as building blocks can be easily identified and chosen based on their defined scope. Composability also increases the potential for reuse, as well-defined building blocks can be repurposed across different solutions. Additionally, it allows for flexibility, as building blocks can be substituted or reconfigured without affecting the overall system, enabling continuous improvement and adaptation to changing requirements."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional ;
    elap:statement "Composability ensures that solutions are divided into modular building blocks that can be aggregated and orchestrated, simplifying their selection, increasing reuse potential, and enabling interchangeability and flexibility."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4842-4398-5_9> ;
    dct:title "Composability"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:conformance-chain a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "EIRA is a reference architecture developed by the European Commission to support the design of interoperable digital public services across EU member states. It defines key architectural building blocks (ABBs) and provides a common vocabulary for public administrations."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:TestEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Conformance chain, organisations must adopt and adhere to selected reference architectures and standards. Business processes should include rigorous conformance assessments and validation steps (e.g. through the Interoperability Test Bed) to ensure that the analysis, design, and implementation of DPS align with the chosen reference architectures and specifications. Technically, solutions must be designed to support interoperability and compliance with established standards, including the use of specific building blocks and components. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to maintain conformance throughout the lifecycle of the solution. Additionally, fostering a culture of adherence to standards and best practices is essential to ensure that all stakeholders understand and commit to the principle of conformance."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Implementing the principle of Conformance chain in the lifecycle of digital public services and solutions is crucial for ensuring consistency, reliability, and interoperability across different levels (e.g., EU, National). By adhering to reference architectures, such as the European Interoperability Reference Architecture (EIRA), organisations can ensure that their solutions align with established standards and best practices. The alignment facilitates the interoperability of components and services, reducing complexity and enhancing the overall quality of the DPS. Conformance also ensures that solutions meet specific requirements and specifications, such as those for eDelivery Access Points, thereby promoting a cohesive and efficient digital ecosystem. Ultimately, conformance supports the creation of robust, scalable, and compliant public services."@en ;
    elap:statement "Conformance chain ensures that the analysis, design, and implementation of Digital Public Services adhere to selected reference architectures and specified requirements, achieving deterministic behaviour and interoperability."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/european-interoperability-reference-architecture-eira/solution/eira> ;
    dct:title "Conformance chain"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:technical .

elap:convergence-on-public-policy-goals-attainment a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:AnalyticsEnablersGrouping,
        eira:ObservabilityAndMonitoringEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "To ensure alignment with public policy objectives, digital public services must clearly address societal needs and be prioritised based on their value and impact. Resources should be allocated efficiently, focusing on services that provide tangible benefits while avoiding unnecessary expenditures. Public administrations must establish systems to monitor and evaluate the progress, efficiency, and outcomes of these services, ensuring they remain aligned with policy goals. Collaboration across government bodies is essential to maintain coherence, with clear accountability for achieving results. Additionally, digital services should be designed to be adaptable and interoperable, enabling seamless collaboration and flexibility to respond to evolving needs. Finally, active engagement with citizens and businesses is vital to ensure services are relevant and effective in addressing real societal challenges."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:obligation ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:nws ;
    elap:rationale """Digital public services are a key instrument for implementing public policies that address real and relevant societal needs. To ensure their success, it is essential that these services are designed, implemented, and monitored in alignment with public policy goals, maximising their efficiency and effectiveness in meeting societal demands.

Public administrations have a dual responsibility: firstly, to evaluate and ensure that resources dedicated to the implementation of digital public services are proportionate to the societal needs they address and the value they provide; secondly, to continuously track and control these efforts to ensure alignment with policy objectives without introducing inefficiencies or unnecessary expenditures.

By combining the assurance of alignment with public policies and ongoing control mechanisms, public administrations can ensure that digital public services deliver tangible benefits, remain sustainable, and uphold the principles of accountability, efficiency, and effectiveness. This principle emphasises the need for strategic coherence, resource optimisation, and consistent evaluation to achieve impactful public policy outcomes."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional ;
    elap:statement "Public administrations must ensure that digital public services are aligned with public policy goals, designed to address societal needs, and monitored for efficiency and effectiveness in their implementation and delivery."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/assessment-effectiveness-and-efficiency> ;
    dct:title "Convergence on public policy goals attainment"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:cost-efficiency a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "This policy paper by the OECD outlines action-oriented principles for building digital public services that are user-focused, resilient, and sustainable. It highlights the importance of cost efficiency by promoting the use of modular, reusable components, open-source solutions, and data-driven decision-making to reduce waste and optimise resource use. The paper underscores how cost-effective design and implementation practices can ensure long-term sustainability and high-quality service delivery."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications """Public administrations should consider cost efficiency throughout the design, implementation, operation and evolution of Digital Public Services.

Organisational processes should be periodically assessed to identify unnecessary complexity, duplication, manual effort and inefficient use of resources. Opportunities for process simplification, standardisation, reuse and automation should be considered where they can improve efficiency without compromising service requirements.

Technical solutions should make proportionate use of infrastructure and other technical resources and, where appropriate, provide mechanisms to monitor resource utilisation and operational performance. Evidence obtained through such monitoring should support the identification of inefficiencies and opportunities for continuous optimisation.

Decisions concerning costs and resource optimisation should consider the entire lifecycle of the Digital Public Service, including implementation, operation, maintenance and evolution, rather than focusing exclusively on initial acquisition or development costs."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """Cost efficiency is essential for ensuring the sustainable provision and evolution of Digital Public Services. It should not be understood solely as minimising financial expenditure, but as achieving the intended outcomes while making appropriate and proportionate use of the resources available.

Digital Public Services should therefore seek to identify and reduce unnecessary costs, effort, duplication and resource consumption across their lifecycle. This requires efficient and well-managed processes, appropriate use of organisational and technical resources, and consideration of opportunities for optimisation, standardisation, reuse and automation where these provide demonstrable benefits.

Continuous monitoring and improvement of processes and operations can contribute to identifying inefficiencies and ensuring that resources remain aligned with changing needs, service demand and technological developments. Cost optimisation should, however, be balanced against other relevant requirements, including service quality, performance, reliability, security and user needs, avoiding short-term savings that could negatively affect the overall value or sustainability of the service."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Cost efficiency ensures that Digital Public Services make effective and proportionate use of financial, organisational and technical resources throughout their lifecycle, continuously optimising processes and operations while maintaining the required level of service quality and performance."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/designing-and-delivering-public-services-in-the-digital-age_e056ef99-en.html> ;
    dct:title "Cost efficiency"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:digital-first-leave-no-one-behind a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The Digital Strategy sets a new vision, addressing digital transformation opportunities of a post-pandemic scenario, and supporting the delivery of the EU’s strategic priorities by 2030."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "Laws and regulations are adapted to remove barriers to digital transformation, enabling the provision of digital services. Public administrations aim to transform existing public services into digital formats, ensuring they can be easily found and accessed by users on their websites. Additionally, digital public services focused on government-to-business interactions are made accessible through automated system interfaces, such as APIs."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:npm ;
    elap:rationale "Making public services digital makes them more accessible, reduces administrative burdens and time and allows faster responses to individuals and organisations. The European Commission has set out a strategy for the digital transformation of its own services, with a preference for digital communication channels. This is also reflected in the EIRA's focus on digital public services, which nonetheless foresees alternative service delivery models besides the primary digital channels."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-functional ;
    elap:statement "Public services are transformed into digital public services, while ensuring that no one is left behind."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://commission.europa.eu/publications/european-commission-digital-strategy_en> ;
    dct:title "Digital first leave no one behind"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational .

elap:digital-partnership a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The Digital Strategy sets a new vision, addressing digital transformation opportunities of a post-pandemic scenario, and supporting the delivery of the EU’s strategic priorities by 2030."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "The creation of Memoranda of Understanding (MoU) and organisational agreements is required to ensure that public institutions are aware of their roles and the roles of others. These agreements should outline the responsibilities, expectations, and contributions of each party, fostering a clear and cooperative framework for collaboration. Public administrations must establish governance structures that facilitate regular communication, coordination, and joint decision-making among partners. This includes setting up cross-organisational teams, holding regular meetings, and using collaborative tools and platforms to share information and resources. Additionally, public bodies should invest in capacity-building initiatives to enhance the skills and competencies of their staff, enabling them to effectively engage in and contribute to digital partnerships. By following these guidelines, public administrations can create strong and sustainable partnerships that drive digital transformation and improve public service delivery."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:npg ;
    elap:rationale "Strong and reliable relationships with other EU institutions and beyond should be fostered to share resources, knowledge, and expertise. These partnerships are essential for staying at the forefront of the latest technological trends and ensuring that digital transformation efforts are aligned with broader strategic goals. By collaborating with various stakeholders, public administrations can leverage diverse perspectives and capabilities, leading to more innovative and effective solutions. Specific approaches in technology, such as user-centric design, data-driven decision-making, and agile methodologies, must be pursued to enhance the responsiveness and adaptability of public services. These collaborative efforts not only improve service delivery but also build a resilient and interconnected digital ecosystem that can better serve the needs of citizens and businesses."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-governance ;
    elap:statement "Public administrations' digital transformation must be based on the identification of cross-organisational needs and the development of internal and external partnerships."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://commission.europa.eu/publications/european-commission-digital-strategy_en> ;
    dct:title "Digital partnership"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:digital-resilience a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource """Digital Resilience of Public Administration in the EU - This resource from the European Commission outlines the components of digital resilience in the public sector, including the enforcement of legislation on cybersecurity and cyber resilience, the availability of reliable critical infrastructures, and the use of appropriate digital and cybersecurity skills.

Business Continuity Plan/Interoperable Europe Portal - This glossary entry defines a business continuity plan as a strategy to ensure that digital public services and their building blocks continue to function in various situations, such as cyberattacks or system failures. It highlights the importance of maintaining service continuity and resilience."""@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Digital resilience, public administrations must adopt practices and technologies that ensure the continuous operation and adaptability of digital public services. This includes designing resilient architectures that can withstand and recover from disruptions, ensuring long-term viability and scalability. Solutions must support real-time monitoring and data-driven decision-making to detect and respond to potential issues promptly. Implementing robust backup and recovery systems is essential for maintaining uninterrupted service delivery during crises. Additionally, fostering a culture of resilience and adaptability among staff through training and capacity-building initiatives is crucial. By embedding these practices into digital public services, public administrations can create a more resilient, adaptable, and trustworthy environment, ultimately improving service delivery and public trust."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Digital resilience is crucial for ensuring the long-term viability, scalability, and efficient resource use of digital public services. It refers to the ability of digital solutions to remain operational and relevant, adapting to changing circumstances and recovering swiftly from disruptions. By focusing on digital resilience, public administrations can ensure that their solutions are environmentally responsible, inclusive, and robust, aligning with broader societal and policy goals. Implementing resilient architectures and practices helps reduce the risk of service interruptions, enhances public trust, and supports the sustainability and scalability of digital public services."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Digital resilience ensures that digital public services are designed and managed to remain operational, relevant, and adaptable over time, guaranteeing their capacity to withstand and recover from disruptions while maintaining uninterrupted service delivery."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://ec.europa.eu/newsroom/cipr/items/806197/>,
        <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/business-continuity-plan> ;
    dct:title "Digital resilience"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:digital-sovereignty a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "This report highlights the importance of digital sovereignty for the EU's economic growth and security. It discusses the need for Europe to regain control over its digital infrastructure and data to ensure strategic autonomy and resilience."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:DataspaceEnablersGrouping,
        eira:SecurityEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "Organisations must adopt technical alternatives that promote cost-effective, sustainable, independent, and secure solutions. This involves conducting prior assessments of the suitability of these alternatives, considering each area of implementation, and taking into account relevant legal frameworks. From a business perspective, it is essential to establish policies that support digital sovereignty, including procurement practices that favour local or European providers and the development of in-house capabilities. Technically, systems must be designed to ensure data sovereignty, with robust data management practices and secure infrastructures that prevent unauthorised access and control by external entities. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to maintain compliance with digital sovereignty requirements and to adapt to evolving threats and challenges."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "European Institutions and Administrations represent citizens and businesses, ensuring the holistic development of European society. By preventing dependency on external stakeholders, this principle helps avoid monopolies and vendor lock-in, which can lead to inefficient solutions and vulnerability to external influences. Digital sovereignty encompasses vendor lock-in, data sovereignty, and platform sovereignty, ensuring that digital solutions are aligned with European strategic interests and values. This principle promotes the development of independent, secure, and sustainable digital infrastructures, enhancing trust and resilience in public services. Furthermore, digital sovereignty serves to protect citizens' rights within the digital domain while shielding them from unauthorised content. Additionally, this principle supports Member States in fostering the growth of the digital economy."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Digital sovereignty ensures that digital infrastructures, products, and services safeguard European security, strategic assets, and interests while respecting European values and requirements."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.eitdigital.eu/fileadmin/files/2020/publications/data-sovereignty/EIT-Digital-Data-Sovereignty-Summary-Report.pdf> ;
    dct:title "Digital sovereignty"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:eu-legislation-compliance a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "EUR-Lex is your online gateway to EU Law. It provides the official and most comprehensive access to EU legal documents. It is available in all of the EU’s 24 official languages and is updated daily."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications """A compliance assessment of EU Directives must be carried out in two stages:
(1) timely and systematic check whether Member States have transposed Union law;
(2) a timely and systematic conformity check of national transposing measures against the relevant Union legislation (correct transposition).

While Member States are responsible for the timely and accurate transposition of directives as well as the correct application of the entire acquis, the Commission has to monitor the Member States’ efforts and ensure that their legislation complies with Union law."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:obligation ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Member States play a key role in ensuring EU law is implemented correctly and in a timely manner. This is essential for people and businesses to optimally benefit from commonly agreed rules."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "EU legislation compliance is the property of (national/local) legislation to be fully aligned with European legislation."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri=cellar:2c2f2554-0faf-11e7-8a35-01aa75ed71a1.0017.02/DOC_3&format=PDF> ;
    dct:title "EU legislation compliance"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:findability a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The authors intended to provide guidelines to improve the Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reuse of digital assets."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:APIEnablersGrouping,
        eira:DataManagementEnablersGrouping,
        eira:DataspaceEnablersGrouping,
        eira:KnowledgeDiscoveryEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "Implementing Findability requires a comprehensive approach that ensures digital resources are easily discoverable and accessible. This involves assigning globally unique and persistent identifiers to all resources, providing rich and standardised metadata to describe them in detail, and ensuring they are indexed in searchable databases. High data quality and adherence to standardised vocabularies and tools are essential to enhance interoperability and reuse. Additionally, integrating metadata and data with digital public services and solutions ensures that citizens can easily find and access the services they need. By adopting these practices, public administrations can improve the accessibility and usability of their digital resources, ultimately enhancing service delivery and citizen satisfaction."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Findability is crucial for maximising the utility and accessibility of digital resources. By implementing globally unique and persistent identifiers, enriched metadata, and robust linking mechanisms, organisations can ensure that their resources are easily discoverable. This approach promotes transparency, efficiency, and user satisfaction by enabling seamless access to information and services. In the context of public administrations, findability enhances the ability to deliver timely and relevant services to citizens, fostering trust and engagement."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:semantic-functional ;
    elap:statement "Findability ensures that digital resources, including data, public services, and solutions, are easily discoverable and accessible for both humans and computers. This principle emphasises the importance of clear identification, rich metadata, and effective search mechanisms."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.go-fair.org/fair-principles/> ;
    dct:title "Findability"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:integrated-horizontal-user-experience a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "An example of integrated horizontal user experience is found in the development of eID."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:SecurityEnablersGrouping,
        eira:UserExperienceManagementEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "Users of digital public services interact with a unified interface that seamlessly supports their tasks, creating the impression of a single cohesive application. This approach ensures that users are not confronted with redundant steps and only need to log in once to complete their tasks. By encapsulating internal complexities and preventing them from being exposed to users, the system maintains a streamlined and efficient user experience, reinforcing the perception of a singular, integrated solution."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:nws ;
    elap:rationale "Users should be optimally supported in their tasks without being burdened by the complexities of multiple organisations, processes, or applications. This principle guides the analysis and design of architectural solutions to enhance the user experience when accessing and using digital public services."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-functional ;
    elap:statement "Users have an integrated experience of digital public services."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://ec.europa.eu/digital-building-blocks/sites/display/DIGITAL/What+is+eID> ;
    dct:title "Integrated horizontal user experience"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:interoperability a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The Interoperable Europe Act aims to enhance digital cooperation and data sharing across EU member states by establishing common standards and frameworks. It seeks to improve public sector efficiency and cross-border services, ensuring seamless interaction between different national systems. This legislation supports the creation of a unified digital market, fostering innovation and economic growth within the EU."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "Organisations must ensure that their systems and services comply with relevant legal frameworks and facilitate cross-border cooperation, aligning with EU regulations such as the GDPR and the Interoperable Europe Act. Effective governance structures must be established to support interoperability, including creating multidisciplinary teams, involving relevant stakeholders, and fostering a culture of collaboration. Data and services must be described using standardised vocabularies and ontologies to ensure consistent interpretation across different systems. This involves using controlled vocabularies, publishing metadata in machine-readable formats, and ensuring that data models are aligned with international standards. Systems must be designed to support the seamless exchange of data and services by adopting open standards and protocols, ensuring data integrity and security, and implementing robust data management practices. Technical solutions should be scalable, flexible, and capable of integrating with other systems. By addressing these aspects and embedding interoperability by design, organisations can create interoperable systems that enhance the efficiency, effectiveness, and resilience of public services across Europe."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:obligation ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Interoperability allows European Institutions and Administrations to collaborate effectively, ensuring the holistic development of European society. By promoting interoperability, organisations can avoid silos, reduce duplication, and enhance efficiency. This principle supports the seamless exchange of data and services across different legal, organisational, semantic, and technical frameworks, fostering innovation and improving public service delivery. Interoperability is crucial for achieving the goals of the Interoperable Europe Act, which aims to create a unified digital space that enhances the mobility of citizens and businesses across the EU. Moreover, considering interoperability at all levels (legal, organisational, semantic, and technical), is a key approach. Interoperability by design ensures that systems and services are built with interoperability as a core requirement, facilitating easier integration and collaboration."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Interoperability ensures that systems, services, and organisations can work together seamlessly across different domains and borders, safeguarding European security, strategic assets, and interests while respecting European values and requirements."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32024R0903> ;
    dct:title "Interoperability"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:level-playing-field a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The position paper underlines the importance of data spaces and though the sovereign sharing of data in creating the future data economy."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "To establish a Level playing field, organisations must adopt policies and practices that promote accessibility and interoperability across all layers of digital public services. Business processes should be designed to ensure that resources are shared fairly and transparently, with clear guidelines to prevent monopolistic practices. Technically, solutions must support open standards and APIs to facilitate resource exchange and ensure that governance frameworks are in place to manage access and usage equitably. Additionally, technical agreements and mechanisms must address the needs and expectations for infrastructure, ensuring that infrastructure resources are shared, reused, and utilised effectively, without implying unfair situations between participants that could extend to the service's end users. Additionally, continuous monitoring and enforcement mechanisms are necessary to maintain a fair competitive landscape and address any emerging monopolistic tendencies. Collaboration and reuse should be encouraged to ensure that all participants can contribute effectively, regardless of their resource levels."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:obligation ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:npg ;
    elap:rationale "Implementing a Level playing field in solution architecture is essential for fostering a fair and competitive environment. It prevents monopolistic situations where a few entities dominate due to their control over vast amounts of resources, including data, infrastructure, and digital services. By ensuring that new entrants face no insurmountable barriers, it encourages innovation and improves the overall quality of services. This principle is pivotal for creating a fair digital public services ecosystem, where collaboration and participation are based on service excellence rather than resource control, ultimately benefiting consumers and promoting a healthy market. For example, public administrations at different levels (State, Regions, Local) should be able to collaborate and join efforts in new services without being limited by their varying levels of resources. Another example, when procuring any kind of digital public service solutions, public administrations should provide as much information as possible to all participants, ensuring that all possible candidates have access to the same information, so all play by the same set of rules resulting in formal equality of opportunity."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "A level playing field ensures that all participants have equal opportunities to collaborate and participate eliminating monopolistic barriers to entry across all layers of digital public services creation."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://design-principles-for-data-spaces.org/> ;
    dct:title "Level playing field"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:loose-coupling a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The position paper underlines the importance of data spaces and though the sovereign sharing of data in creating the future data economy. It has been combined with existing sources in ELAP related to the theory and practice of the application of systems theory in organisations."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:APIEnablersGrouping,
        eira:ApplicationIntegrationInfrastructureEnablersGrouping,
        eira:DataManagementEnablersGrouping,
        eira:DataspaceEnablersGrouping,
        eira:OrchestrationEnablersGrouping,
        eira:OrchestrationInfrastructureEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """Digital solutions and public services should minimise unnecessary dependencies between architectural building blocks, systems and participating organisations. Dependencies that are necessary should be explicit, documented and managed.

Interactions should rely on well-defined interfaces, contracts and interoperable mechanisms that avoid exposing or depending unnecessarily on the internal implementation of other architectural elements. Open standards and commonly agreed specifications should be used where appropriate to facilitate interoperability and reduce implementation-specific dependencies.

Architectural elements should, where feasible, be capable of evolving, being maintained or being replaced without requiring disproportionate changes to other elements of the solution. Changes to interfaces and contracts should therefore be governed and managed throughout their lifecycle to limit their impact on dependent elements.

Appropriate interaction patterns should be selected according to the architectural context to reduce unnecessary temporal, technical, data or organisational dependencies while maintaining the required level of interoperability, security, performance and reliability."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """Digital public services frequently depend on multiple systems, components and organisations that need to interact while evolving at different speeds. Excessive or implicit dependencies increase architectural complexity and can cause changes in one element to require changes in others, reducing flexibility and increasing the cost and risk of maintaining or evolving the service.

Loose Coupling limits these dependencies by promoting interactions through clearly defined interfaces, contracts and interoperability mechanisms rather than through unnecessary knowledge of internal implementations. This enables architectural elements to evolve, be maintained or, where appropriate, be replaced with limited impact on other parts of the solution.

Loose Coupling therefore contributes to adaptable, maintainable and resilient digital public services and facilitates interoperability across organisational and technical boundaries. It complements Separation of Concerns: once responsibilities and boundaries have been appropriately established, Loose Coupling ensures that dependencies and interactions across those boundaries remain controlled."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional ;
    elap:statement "Loose coupling ensures that dependencies between architectural building blocks, systems and organisations are minimised and explicitly managed, allowing them to interact while retaining sufficient independence to evolve and change."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://design-principles-for-data-spaces.org/> ;
    dct:title "Loose coupling"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:maintainability a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "This policy paper by the OECD outlines action-oriented principles for building digital public services that are user-driven, resilient, and adaptable. It emphasises the importance of designing services that are maintainable—meaning they can evolve over time to meet changing user needs, technological advancements, and regulatory requirements. The paper highlights the need for transparent, well-documented, and modular systems that support continuous improvement and long-term sustainability."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "Digital public services that strive for Maintainability need to be conceived for this purpose from their initial design and implementation. Practices and methodologies need to be put in place to ensure that all elements that constitute the service, including IT solutions, services and organisational processes, are transparent, well-documented, and flexible to accommodate change."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Maintainability for digital public services is crucial as it ensures they can continue to efficiently meet the evolving needs of users, adapt to technological advancements, and new organisational practices, and comply with changing regulations over time. Maintainability also ensures that investments in time, cost and effort to put in place the initial service offering are not repeated but rather capitalised upon when service evolution is required."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Maintainability for digital public services refers to the ease with which IT solutions, service and organisational processes can be updated, corrected, and improved over time to ensure the service remains functional, efficient and up to date with the needs of the service's users."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/designing-and-delivering-public-services-in-the-digital-age_e056ef99-en.html> ;
    dct:title "Maintainability"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:technical .

elap:measurability a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "This policy paper outlines action-oriented principles for building effective digital public services, including the importance of defining and using metrics and KPIs to assess performance. It emphasises that measurability is essential for transparency, accountability, and continuous improvement, enabling governments to evaluate service effectiveness and align outcomes with user needs and policy goals."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:AnalyticsEnablersGrouping,
        eira:ObservabilityAndMonitoringEnablersGrouping,
        eira:SecurityEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """Public administrations should define relevant and measurable indicators for digital public services and solutions, taking into account their objectives, expected outcomes and applicable service or performance requirements.

Architectures should enable the collection, processing and reporting of the information necessary to assess these indicators. Where appropriate, solutions should incorporate monitoring, observability and analytics capabilities that provide sufficient visibility into their operation and performance.

Measurement mechanisms should be maintained throughout the lifecycle of the service so that performance can be periodically assessed, deviations can be identified, and evidence can support decisions concerning optimisation and continuous improvement.

Monitoring and measurement should be proportionate to their intended purpose. The collection of logs, metrics, telemetry or other operational information should be limited to what is necessary and designed in accordance with Security by Design, Privacy by Design and applicable data protection requirements. Where the same monitoring capabilities support multiple concerns, such as performance measurement and security monitoring, they should be designed to enable appropriate reuse while maintaining a clear separation of purpose."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """Measurability enables public administrations to determine whether digital public services and solutions are performing as intended and contributing to their defined objectives. Establishing relevant and measurable indicators supports evidence-based evaluation, transparency, accountability and continuous improvement by providing objective information on service performance and outcomes.

Measurability should be considered from the design stage so that the information required to assess relevant indicators can be obtained throughout the lifecycle of the service. Depending on the nature of the solution, this may require appropriate monitoring, observability and analytics capabilities to collect and process information about service operation and performance.

These capabilities may also support other architectural concerns, particularly Security by Design, through mechanisms such as monitoring and logging. However, their purpose within Measurability is specifically to provide the information required to assess service performance and the achievement of defined objectives. The collection and use of such information must remain proportionate to the measurement objectives and consistent with applicable security, privacy and data protection requirements."""@en ;
    elap:statement "Digital public services and solutions should be designed so that their performance, operation and achievement of relevant objectives can be objectively measured and assessed through appropriate indicators and metrics."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/designing-and-delivering-public-services-in-the-digital-age_e056ef99-en.html> ;
    dct:title "Measurability"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:multilingualism a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:TranslationEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications """Multilingualism is taken into account at all levels in the design of European digital public services, e.g. also in documentation and systems interfaces.
A balance needs to be found between the expectations of citizens and businesses to be served in their own language(s) or their preferred language(s) and the ability of Member States’ public administrations to offer services in all official EU languages.
A suitable balance could be that European public services are available in the languages of the expected end-users, i.e. the number of languages is decided on the basis of users’ needs, such as the level to which the service is critical for the implementation of the digital single market or national policies, or the size of the relevant audience."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "European public services can potentially be used by anyone in any Member State. So Multilingualism needs to be carefully considered when designing them. Citizens across Europe often have problems accessing and using digital public services if these are not available in the languages they speak."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional ;
    elap:statement "European digital public services are multilingual."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/multilingualism> ;
    dct:title "Multilingualism"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:openness a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """Refers to the idea that all public data should be freely available for use and reuse by others unless restrictions apply e.g. for the protection of personal data, confidentiality, or intellectual property rights.

Also, refers to ensuring a level playing field for open-source software and demonstrating active and fair consideration of using open-source software, taking into account the total cost of ownership of the solution.

And last but not least, give preference to open specifications, taking due account of the coverage of functional needs, maturity and market support and innovation."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "This principle is based on three pillars: the openness of public administration's data, the openness of the software used and implemented and the openness of standards and specifications used to develop digital public services."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "In the context of interoperable public services, the concept of Openness mainly relates to data, specifications and software."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.3> ;
    dct:title "Openness"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:portability a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:APIEnablersGrouping,
        eira:DataManagementEnablersGrouping,
        eira:TestEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "Implementing the principle of Portability requires both business and technical considerations. This involves adopting open and standard protocols and formats to make data and services accessible outside their original applications. Public administrations must establish policies and frameworks that support the seamless transfer and integration of digital assets across different systems and platforms. Technically, systems must be designed to support interoperability with robust data management practices and secure infrastructures that facilitate the easy movement of data and services. Additionally, public bodies should promote the use of common standards and best practices to ensure that digital solutions can be easily adapted and reused in different contexts. By following these guidelines, public administrations can achieve a more efficient, flexible, and interoperable digital ecosystem, enhancing the overall effectiveness of public services."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Portability provides significant benefits for public administrations and citizens. The functioning of the digital single market requires that data, services, and solutions be easily transferable among different systems to avoid lock-in and support the free movement of digital assets. This principle ensures that public administrations can efficiently reuse existing digital solutions, enhancing interoperability and reducing costs associated with developing new systems. Portability is particularly crucial in cross-border scenarios, where the ability to move and reuse data and services across different jurisdictions is essential for fostering collaboration and innovation. By ensuring portability, public administrations can provide more flexible, efficient, and user-centric services, ultimately improving the overall quality of public service delivery."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance ;
    elap:statement "Portability ensures that data, digital public services, and solutions can be easily transferred, reused, and integrated across different systems and platforms, supporting the seamless movement and interoperability within the digital single market."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri=cellar:2c2f2554-0faf-11e7-8a35-01aa75ed71a1.0017.02/DOC_1&format=PDF> ;
    dct:title "Portability"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:preservation-of-information a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:DataManagementEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "Records are accompanied by metadata that supports records management and archiving, and they are stored in formats that ensure long-term accessibility, including the preservation of associated electronic signatures or seals. During their retention period, records are preserved and selected for deletion afterward. They are converted to recent standard formats while also keeping the original version in its original format. When old media become obsolete, records are converted to new media as necessary. Additionally, records that are not strictly national are governed by an appropriate preservation policy to address any difficulties arising from the use of relevant information under different jurisdictions."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Legislation requires that decisions and data are stored and can be accessed for a specified time. This includes all data and information in the electronic form held by public administrations for the purpose of documenting procedures and decisions. The goal is to ensure that records and other forms of information keep their legibility, reliability and integrity and can be accessed as long as needed subject to security and privacy provisions."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-governance ;
    elap:statement "Records are preserved and made long-term accessible."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.12> ;
    dct:title "Preservation of information"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:privacy a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:DataManagementEnablersGrouping,
        eira:PrivacyEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """Public administrations should identify privacy and data protection requirements from the earliest stages of service and solution design and implement appropriate technical and organisational measures throughout their lifecycle.

Personal data should only be collected and processed when necessary for specified and legitimate purposes and on an appropriate legal basis. Solutions should minimise the personal data collected and processed and avoid unnecessary collection, retention, duplication or disclosure.

Where appropriate, privacy-enhancing measures such as anonymisation, pseudonymisation, encryption and access controls should be incorporated into the architecture. Access to personal data should be limited according to legitimate needs and responsibilities.

Solutions should provide appropriate transparency concerning the processing of personal data and support the exercise of applicable data subject rights. Where processing is likely to result in high risks to individuals, appropriate data protection impact assessments should be conducted.

Privacy requirements should also be considered when information is exchanged or reused across organisations and public services. Interoperability and data sharing should be designed so that they do not undermine the protection of personal data. Privacy measures should be regularly reviewed and updated to reflect changes in the solution, its processing activities, identified risks and applicable requirements."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """Digital public services may involve the collection, exchange and processing of personal data. Protecting this data and respecting individuals' rights are essential to maintaining trust and ensuring compliance with applicable data protection legislation, including the GDPR.

Privacy should therefore be considered throughout the lifecycle of digital solutions and public services and not only as a compliance activity performed after their design. The processing of personal data should have an appropriate legal basis and follow applicable data protection principles, including purpose limitation, data minimisation, accuracy, storage limitation, integrity and confidentiality, transparency and accountability.

Applying Privacy by Design helps ensure that architectures and processes limit unnecessary collection, processing, retention and exposure of personal data and incorporate appropriate safeguards from the outset. This is particularly relevant where solutions involve extensive data sharing, sensitive personal data, automated decision-making or artificial intelligence."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance ;
    elap:statement "Personal data is processed lawfully, fairly, transparently and securely, with privacy and data protection requirements integrated into the design and operation of digital solutions and public services from the outset and throughout their lifecycle."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.4> ;
    dct:title "Privacy"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:proactiveness a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "Interoperable Europe Portal is a collaborative platform on interoperability with the aim: \"to provide a common venue that enables public administrations, businesses and citizens to share and reuse IT solutions and good practices, and facilitate communication and collaboration on IT projects across Europe\", created by the European Commission and funded by the European Union via the Interoperability solutions for public administrations, businesses and citizens (ISA2) Programme. It can be regarded as an example of proactiveness."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "For the implementation of Proactiveness in digital public services, there are implications at various levels. At the legal level, it is essential to ensure that data is treated and managed in accordance with relevant legal clauses. At the organisational level, digital capabilities must be instantiated by services aligned with user needs and governed by agreements between parties to ensure data sovereignty. Legal interoperability requires that data is properly described and adheres to current approaches for semantic interoperability. At the technical level, it is crucial to ensure that appropriate technical applications and technology services are available to reuse and deliver these services effectively."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """European institutions and public administrations throughout Europe are reference actors and roles that can lead the environment on digital public services and the use of available data for the creation of innovative services, taking as a basis life, business events and circumstances.

There is an increasing amount of data from citizens, businesses and other stakeholders that European institutions can leverage to think and create digital public services according to users' needs (citizens or businesses)."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Proactiveness refers to proactive services, which are public services that a public institution delivers following its own initiatives."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/> ;
    dct:title "Proactiveness"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:proportionality a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Proportionality, organisations must conduct thorough impact assessments to ensure that measures are necessary and appropriate. Business processes should include regular reviews and evaluations to assess the proportionality of actions taken. Technically, solutions must be designed to be scalable and adaptable, allowing for adjustments based on ongoing assessments. Clear guidelines and criteria should be established to determine the necessity and appropriateness of measures, ensuring that they align with the overall objectives and do not impose excessive burdens. Public bodies must also ensure that access to information is justified and limited to data within their control or governance."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Implementing the Proportionality principle when developing and providing solutions ensures that actions and measures are balanced and justified, avoiding unnecessary complexity and resource expenditure. This principle helps to maintain a focus on efficiency and effectiveness, ensuring that solutions are designed to meet objectives without overstepping or imposing undue burdens on stakeholders. By adhering to proportionality, organisations can optimise resource allocation and enhance the sustainability of public services. Additionally, limiting access to information ensures that public bodies only access data that is necessary and within their governance, protecting privacy and data integrity."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-governance ;
    elap:statement "Limitation to the necessary actions to achieve public administrations' objectives, ensuring the delivery with appropriate measures and not imposing excessive burdens."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.2> ;
    dct:title "Proportionality"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational .

elap:reference-architecture a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "EIRA is a reference architecture developed by the European Commission to support the design of interoperable digital public services across EU member states. It defines key architectural building blocks (ABBs) and provides a common vocabulary for public administrations."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Reference architecture, organisations must adopt and align with relevant reference architectures from the inception phase of digital public service design. Business processes should include rigorous assessments to ensure alignment with selected reference architectures, such as the European Interoperability Reference Architecture (EIRA). Technically, solutions must be designed to support interoperability and scalability, incorporating modular and reusable components. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to maintain alignment with reference architectures and address any emerging issues. Additionally, fostering a culture of adherence to reference architectures and best practices is essential to ensure that all stakeholders understand and commit to the principle. Training and capacity-building initiatives should be implemented to equip staff with the knowledge and skills needed to apply reference architectures effectively. The principle of \"Conformance chain\" further reinforces this by requiring that all stages of digital public service development conform to the selected reference architectures, ensuring consistency and reliability."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "The use of Reference architecture in digital public service creation is crucial for ensuring consistency, reliability, and quality across digital public services. Reference architectures provide a standardised framework that guides the design and implementation of systems, ensuring they align with best practices and established standards. This approach helps to streamline development processes, reduce complexity, and enhance the interoperability of different systems. By adhering to reference architectures, organisations can ensure that their solutions are scalable, reusable, and capable of meeting diverse user needs. Additionally, reference architectures support the alignment of digital public services with strategic goals and regulatory requirements, fostering a cohesive and efficient digital ecosystem."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "The assimilation, alignment and use of Reference architecture ensure that digital public services are designed and implemented based on relevant methodologies and frameworks from the inception phase. It helps to ensure the alignment of digital public services with relevant user needs covering layers of the service and ensuring its reuse and scalability."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/european-interoperability-reference-architecture-eira/solution/eira> ;
    dct:title "Reference architecture"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:reuse-before-buy-before-build a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "Public administrations should assess existing assets before acquiring or developing new ones. For software and digital solutions, this assessment should follow a reuse before buy before build approach: existing systems, services, components and other reusable solutions should first be evaluated for fitness for purpose; where these cannot fulfil the requirements, available software products, including COTS solutions, should be considered and evaluated for functionality, interoperability, scalability, security, maintainability, adaptability and integration with the existing architecture. Development of a new solution should be considered where reuse or acquisition cannot adequately satisfy the identified requirements. For data and information, public administrations should determine whether the information required by a service is already available and suitable for reuse before collecting it again. Appropriate catalogues, metadata, interfaces and data-sharing mechanisms should support the discovery, access and reuse of information across organisational boundaries. Where legally and technically possible, information already held by public administrations should be reused instead of being requested again from citizens or businesses. Across both dimensions, reusable assets should be sufficiently documented and should use interoperable standards, interfaces and data models where appropriate. Their reuse must take into account applicable legal, organisational, semantic, security and technical requirements."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Reusing existing assets enables public administrations to make efficient use of available resources and investments while avoiding unnecessary duplication. For software and digital solutions, existing systems, services and components should first be assessed for reuse. Where suitable reusable solutions are not available, existing software products, including Commercial Off-The-Shelf (COTS) solutions, should be considered before developing new solutions from scratch. This can reduce development and maintenance costs, implementation risks and time to deployment, while promoting the use of proven solutions. Reusability also applies to data and information. Information already available within public administrations should, where legally and organisationally permitted, be shared and reused rather than collected repeatedly. This contributes to improved consistency and data quality and supports the once-only approach, reducing the administrative burden on citizens and businesses."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Existing solutions, services, data and information should be reused whenever appropriate before acquiring or developing new ones, or requesting information that is already available."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/reusability> ;
    dct:title "Reuse, before buy, before build"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:scalability a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "This document is a report developed by the BRIDGE Scalability and Replicability Task Force, provides a structured methodology to assess the scalability and replicability of smart grid and energy storage solutions in EU-funded projects. It outlines additional subroutines, scientific background, and state-of-the-art practices to support consistent implementation across diverse contexts. The guidelines aim to enhance the impact and transferability of innovative energy technologies across Europe."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "Achieving Scalability involves leveraging modern and flexible infrastructure to accommodate fluctuations in user needs or system processing demands, ensuring continuity and efficiency even under growing workloads or during periods of high demand. Scalable public services should also be designed to enable reuse and interoperability, allowing for the efficient adaptation and expansion of solutions across borders and contexts."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Scalability is crucial for ensuring that systems can efficiently handle growth in demand, whether due to increased traffic, data volume, or user activity. It supports business continuity enabling failure recovery and adaptation to unforeseen changes. Furthermore scalability ensures regulation compliance in cases where resiliency and the gracefully handling of increased demand are key aspects in the delivery of digital public services."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Scalability is the measure of a system’s ability to increase or decrease in performance and cost in response to changes in application and system processing demands."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://bridge-smart-grid-storage-systems-digital-projects.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/bridge-reports/guidelines%20for%20implementing%20the%20prescribed%20technology-MJ0322251ENN.pdf> ;
    dct:title "Scalability"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:technical .

elap:security-by-design a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:TrustInfrastructureEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """Public administrations should identify security requirements and risks from the earliest stages of solution design and review them throughout the solution lifecycle. Appropriate organisational and technical security measures should be incorporated into the architecture according to the nature of the information and services concerned and the identified risks.

Solutions should protect sensitive information against unauthorised access and disclosure and protect information against unauthorised or improper modification, corruption and destruction. Appropriate measures should include, where applicable, information classification, access controls based on roles and responsibilities, secure authentication and authorisation mechanisms, and appropriate cryptographic mechanisms for information at rest and in transit.

Solutions should incorporate mechanisms that enable the integrity and authenticity of information to be verified, particularly when information is exchanged between systems or organisations. Where accountability for specific actions or transactions is required, solutions should also provide appropriate verifiable evidence supporting non-repudiation. Depending on the context and level of assurance required, this may include cryptographic mechanisms, digital signatures, qualified trust services, secure logging and audit mechanisms supporting integrity, authenticity and non-repudiation.

Changes to information and relevant system resources should be appropriately controlled and, where required, traceable. Logging, audit trails and monitoring mechanisms should support the detection and investigation of unauthorised modifications and other security incidents and provide appropriate accountability.

Security measures should address relevant security properties, including confidentiality, integrity, availability, authenticity and non-repudiation, according to the needs and risk profile of the service. Architectures should also support secure information exchange across organisational boundaries and appropriate identity and trust management mechanisms.

Security should be continuously maintained through appropriate monitoring, vulnerability and incident management, auditing, testing, updating and regular review of security controls. Security responsibilities should be clearly established, and relevant personnel should have appropriate security awareness and training."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """Security should be treated as an inherent architectural concern rather than as a set of measures added after a solution has been designed. Security requirements and controls should therefore be considered throughout the entire lifecycle of digital solutions and public services and be proportionate to the identified risks.

Security by Design encompasses the protection of information, systems and services, including their confidentiality, integrity and availability, together with other relevant security properties such as authenticity and non-repudiation. Confidentiality protects sensitive information against unauthorised access and disclosure, while integrity protects information against unauthorised or improper modification, corruption or destruction and provides assurance that information has not been improperly altered during its storage, processing or exchange. Non-repudiation supports accountability by providing verifiable evidence of relevant actions or transactions, helping to ensure that their origin, submission, receipt or approval cannot subsequently be unjustifiably denied.

Integrating these security considerations from the outset reduces vulnerabilities and the risks of unauthorised access, disclosure, alteration, loss or disruption. It contributes to maintaining trust in digital public services, supports secure information exchange across organisational boundaries, improves resilience and facilitates compliance with applicable security, cybersecurity and other regulatory requirements."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance ;
    elap:statement "Security is integrated into the design, development, deployment and operation of digital solutions and public services from the outset and throughout their lifecycle, ensuring appropriate protection of information, systems and services, including their confidentiality, integrity and availability."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.4> ;
    dct:title "Security by design"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:separation-of-concerns a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "In the source, an article, the principle is revised. The principle of separation of concerns finds application to a number of aspects of software development, some well-known, such as de-coupling modules, some less well-known, such as organising case analyses. Three example applications of the principle of separation of concerns are presented, with the aim of helping the reader to apply the principle better and to find new situations in which the principle can be applied."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """Digital solutions and public services should be decomposed into architectural building blocks with clearly defined responsibilities, capabilities and boundaries. Each building block should address a coherent set of concerns, and unnecessary duplication or overlap of responsibilities between building blocks should be avoided.

The responsibilities and interfaces of architectural building blocks should be explicitly defined and documented so that their role within the overall architecture can be clearly understood and governed.

The separation of concerns should be maintained throughout the lifecycle of the solution. Changes and extensions should respect established responsibility boundaries and avoid introducing functionality into components where it does not logically belong.

Separation should be applied at the appropriate architectural levels, including organisational processes, information and data responsibilities, applications, services and technical components, according to the nature and complexity of the digital public service."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """Separating concerns reduces architectural complexity by ensuring that each building block addresses a coherent set of responsibilities and capabilities. Clear boundaries help prevent unrelated or duplicated functionality from being distributed across multiple parts of a solution and make the architecture easier to understand, govern and maintain.

Separation of Concerns supports modular solution design by allowing individual architectural elements to be designed, developed, tested and maintained according to their specific responsibilities. It also improves accountability by making it clearer which components or organisational actors are responsible for particular capabilities.

Clear separation of responsibilities provides the architectural foundation for managing dependencies between building blocks. In this sense, Separation of Concerns complements Loose Coupling: Separation of Concerns establishes appropriate boundaries, while Loose Coupling ensures that dependencies across those boundaries are minimised and appropriately managed."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional ;
    elap:statement "Separation of concerns ensures that the responsibilities and capabilities of a digital solution or service are organised into distinct architectural building blocks with clear and well-defined scopes."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780080362366500084> ;
    dct:title "Separation of concerns"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:service-orientation a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The Open Group is a global consortium that enables the achievement of business objectives through IT standards."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:APIEnablersGrouping,
        eira:ApplicationIntegrationInfrastructureEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """At the organisational level, public administrations need to establish the proper agreements that allow collaboration and common mechanisms to provide relevant information through the desired Service Oriented Architecture.

At the technical level, the organisations in charge of implementing and delivery of digital public services will need to determine which is the best approach to fit their needs. There are different approaches such as SAP, RESTApi or GraphQL, taking into account the relevant aspects of the services, the organisation responsible for the service should select the more sustainable and efficient way of implementing the SOA approach."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale """Being user-centred or remaining "user-led," is possible with a service-oriented strategy. It entails offering services that employ the best technological solutions to provide better results. By making this change, the organisation will put user demands and goals at the centre of its vision, culture, and operations. Then, make sure that everyone supports it and owns it so that decisions and technology are driven by user demands.

A service-oriented strategy entails developing an IT platform made up of numerous systems, each one tailored to carry out particular tasks. You can change one aspect of a system's functionality with a tech stack made up of separate components without changing the operation of the entire system. Certain components can be digitalised more quickly because of this function fragmentation, which also offers a distribution strategy that allows for independently distributed functions. Communication with external programs is also made possible by separate systems where each software tool is designed to carry out a specific task using a well-defined interface.

There are a variety of technologies that can be applied to this service orientation approach such as SOAP, REST API and GraphQL."""@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Service orientation is a way of thinking in terms of services and service-based development and the outcomes of services."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://web.archive.org/web/20160819141303/http://opengroup.org/soa/source-book/soa/soa.htm> ;
    dct:title "Service orientation"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:social-participation a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "ECAS is implementing a Digital Democracy Agenda, aiming to explore the democratic potential of ICT."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "Systems must be designed to support collaborative governance, with tools and platforms that facilitate stakeholder engagement and participation. Public administrations must adopt policies and frameworks that promote the active involvement of all stakeholders, ensuring that their needs and perspectives are considered in the design, creation, and maintenance of digital public services. Additionally, policies should be implemented to ensure that citizens and businesses are at the core of these initiatives, fostering a culture of transparency and accountability."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:not-applicable ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:npg ;
    elap:rationale "The integration of Social participation and public-private governance provides significant benefits for the development and maintenance of digital public services. A sound governance model is essential for creating a level playing field where all stakeholders feel represented and engaged. This includes users (individuals and organisations), service providers, and technology partners. By involving all relevant parties, public administrations can ensure that the solutions developed are comprehensive, effective, and aligned with the needs and expectations of all stakeholders. The approach of this principle fosters collaboration, innovation, and trust, which are crucial for the successful implementation and sustainability of digital public services. It can help to ease the creation of more effective public services, communication and interaction between citizens and various levels of government."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-governance ;
    elap:statement "Social participation fosters and ensures that all stakeholders, including users, service providers, technology partners, and professionals, are represented and engaged in the design, creation, and maintenance of digital public services. This approach promotes civic participation and transparency in government decision-making processes, particularly concerning ICT policies."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://ecas.org/digital-democracy/> ;
    dct:title "Social participation"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational .

elap:solution-fit a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The \"Solutions Architect's Handbook\" is a comprehensive guide designed to help aspiring and experienced solutions architects excel in their roles. The book covers essential concepts, design principles, and patterns necessary for creating secure and reliable architectures. Additionally, the Public Procurement Directive (Directive 2014/24/EU): This directive establishes the rules for public procurement, emphasising that the procurement process should ensure the best value for money, which involves selecting solutions that best meet the specified requirements."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement the Solution fit principle, organisations must conduct thorough requirement analysis and ensure that the selected solution addresses all relevant levels—organisational, semantic, and technical. Business processes should include rigorous evaluation and selection criteria to match solutions with requirements accurately. Technically, solutions must be assessed for compatibility, scalability, and alignment with existing systems and standards. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to ensure that the solution remains fit for purpose as requirements evolve."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Ensuring the chosen solution meets the specific requirements, and therefore the needs and expectations of the public services is crucial to ensure efficient and effective service provision. By carefully selecting the appropriate solution, organisations can achieve optimal performance, cost-efficiency, and alignment with their strategic goals. This principle helps avoid mismatches between requirements and solutions, which can lead to inefficiencies, increased costs, and project failures. Ensuring a proper fit enhances the overall effectiveness and success of the solution."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "The selected solution/approach is the best possible aligned with the requirements."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://openlibrary.org/books/OL37329774M/Solutions_Architect%27s_Handbook_-_Second_Edition> ;
    dct:title "Solution fit"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:subsidiarity a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Subsidiarity, organisations must establish governance structures that empower local and regional authorities to make decisions. Business processes should be designed to facilitate localised decision-making, including mechanisms for citizen engagement and feedback. Technically, solutions must support decentralised data management and interoperability to ensure that local systems can operate independently while still integrating with broader frameworks. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to ensure that decisions made at the local level are effective and aligned with overall objectives."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Implementing the Subsidiarity principle in public administrations solutions ensures that decisions are made at the level closest to the citizens, enhancing responsiveness and accountability. This principle helps to safeguard the ability of Member States to take action and make decisions that best address their specific needs and contexts. By promoting localised decision-making, subsidiarity fosters greater engagement and trust among citizens, leading to more effective and tailored public services."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance ;
    elap:statement "The Subsidiarity principle requires decisions to be taken as closely as possible to the citizen, ensuring that actions are taken at the most effective level, whether local, regional, or national."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.2> ;
    dct:title "Subsidiarity"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal .

elap:technology-neutrality a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications """Laws and regulations do not require the use of any specific technology and do not favour nor discriminate against any technology.
It is possible to adhere to the laws and regulations with solutions and technologies from different manufacturers, developers, suppliers and distributors."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Regulations tied to a particular technology may quickly become obsolete and require further amendment. Also, technology-specific regulations lead to dependency on specific manufacturers, developers, suppliers or distributors of technology or services. It guarantees freedom of choice by not forcing users into using any specific technology."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Laws and regulations are technology neutral."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/technological-neutrality-and-data-portability> ;
    dct:title "Technology neutrality"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:transparency a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:APIEnablersGrouping,
        eira:ApplicationIntegrationInfrastructureEnablersGrouping,
        eira:BlockchainEnablersGrouping,
        eira:DataManagementEnablersGrouping,
        eira:ObservabilityAndMonitoringEnablersGrouping,
        eira:SecurityEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement Transparency, organisations must adopt practices that ensure openness and accessibility of information across all phases of digital public services. Business processes should include clear guidelines for data transparency, ensuring that data and metadata are available through standardised mechanisms and maintained for long-term availability. Decision-making processes should be documented and made accessible to stakeholders, providing insights into the rationale and criteria used. Technically, solutions must support real-time data access, user-friendly interfaces, and robust security measures to protect sensitive information while ensuring transparency. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to maintain transparency and address any emerging issues. Legal and regulatory frameworks should be established/referenced to support and enforce transparency measures, ensuring compliance and promoting a high level of public sector integrity."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Transparency in digital public services and solutions is crucial for fostering trust, accountability, auditability and engagement among citizens and stakeholders. Transparency in digital public services ensures that data is easily accessible, understandable, and usable, promoting better decision-making and enhancing public trust. By making information about how data is collected, processed, and used openly available, organisations can demonstrate their commitment to ethical practices and accountability. Transparency in decision-making processes allows stakeholders to understand the rationale behind decisions, fostering a sense of inclusion and participation. Moreover, it also allows stakeholders to evaluate actions, decisions and outcomes, by providing a clear, traceable record of activities. Thus, administrations can demonstrate their commitment to ethical practices, continuous improvement, foster trust, and enhance public engagement. Overall, transparency supports the creation of a more open, responsive, and trustworthy public sector, driving innovation and improving service delivery."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-functional ;
    elap:statement "Transparency ensures that all phases and aspects of digital public services and solutions, including data, decisions, and processes, are open, accessible, accountable, evaluable and understandable to all stakeholders."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services> ;
    dct:title "Transparency"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:trust a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource """Trust and security in digital government interactions
Everyone should be able to navigate the digital world safely, authenticate and be digitally recognised within the EU conveniently. All people of Europe should avail of an easy to use, widely accepted and secure electronic identification conforming to European standards (e-ID), which allows them to securely access public, private and cross-border digital services. As a broad acceptance of digital government depends on trust, we must ensure that citizens and businesses are able to rely on trustworthy and verifiable digital government applications and services, which are in full conformity with high-security standards and respond to user needs. Moreover, to ensure a free, open and safe digital domain and enhance social trust, fundamental rights and security should be integrated on all policies with a digital dimension. To foster trust in digital interactions with the public sector, suitable regulatory frameworks must be provided that ensure transparency, predictability, security-by-design and, where necessary, reinforcement or adjustment of existing provisions."""@en ;
    elap:associatedABB eira:SecurityEnablersGrouping,
        eira:TrustEnablersGrouping ;
    elap:category category:strategy ;
    elap:implications """The principle has a horizontal approach, where it affects the adoption of legal measures, organisational mechanisms, and technical means to ensure services are part of a network of trustworthiness interactions.

At the legal level, relevant and binding legislation needs to be put in place to ensure legal interoperability and guarantee that trust is the base of data interactions (exchange, processing, etc, amongst digital public services).

At the technical level, mechanisms, tools, and standards should be part of the certification of processes, ensuring that data exchanges between stakeholders are saved with built-in integrity and trust provisions."""@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Trust entails citizens' reliance on trustworthy and verifiable digital government applications and services, which fully conform to high-security standards and respond to user needs. Fundamental rights and security should be integrated into all policies with a digital dimension. To foster trust in digital interactions with the public sector, suitable regulatory frameworks that ensure transparency, predictability, security-by-design and, where necessary, reinforcement or adjustment of existing provisions must be provided."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-governance ;
    elap:statement "The organisation behind digital public services and the data managed need to incorporate the relevant mechanisms to ensure overall trustworthiness."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/trust> ;
    dct:title "Trust"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:uncertainty-management a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The document titled \"Decisions Under Uncertainty\" by Hubbard Decision Research provides a comprehensive overview of probabilistic models and Monte Carlo methods for decision-making. It emphasises the importance of explicitly modelling uncertainty to improve decision outcomes. The document covers topics such as risk tolerance, the value of information, and the application of Applied Information Economics (AIE) to optimise decisions by focusing measurements where they matter most."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "Organisations must adopt practices that recognise and address the limitations in information and knowledge. Business processes should include thorough risk assessments and scenario planning to anticipate and mitigate potential uncertainties. Technically, solutions must be designed to be flexible and adaptable, capable of handling incomplete or evolving information. Continuous monitoring and feedback mechanisms are essential to update and refine solutions as new information becomes available."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Uncertainty management is crucial for recognising and managing the inherent limitations in knowledge and information. By acknowledging uncertainty, organisations can make more informed decisions, anticipate potential risks, and develop strategies to mitigate them. This principle helps improve the quality of problem descriptions and solutions by encouraging thorough analysis and consideration of various possible outcomes. Addressing uncertainty enhances the robustness and adaptability of Digital Public Services, ensuring they can effectively operate in partially observable or stochastic environments."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Uncertainty management acknowledges the degree of confidence in decisions made during the analysis and design of Digital Public Services, arising from imperfect, unknown, or partial information."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://hubbardresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Decisions-Under-Uncertainty-23-July-2020-PDF.pdf> ;
    dct:title "Uncertainty management"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:use-of-standards a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The Interoperable Europe Act aims to enhance digital cooperation and data sharing across EU member states by establishing common standards and frameworks. It seeks to improve public sector efficiency and cross-border services, ensuring seamless interaction between different national systems. This legislation supports the creation of a unified digital market, fostering innovation and economic growth within the EU."@en ;
    elap:category category:implementation ;
    elap:implications "To effectively implement the Use of standards, organisations must adopt and adhere to relevant standards and specifications throughout the design and development process. Business processes should include rigorous conformance assessments and validation steps to ensure compliance with selected standards. Technically, solutions must be designed to support interoperability and compatibility with established standards, including the use of specific protocols, formats, and interfaces. Continuous monitoring and evaluation are necessary to maintain compliance and address any emerging issues. The use of mechanisms and methods for analysing and assessing specifications against specific constraints or frameworks are valuable tools to ensure interoperable digital public services. The Common Assessment Method for Standards and Specifications (CAMSS) is an example of an action and set of solutions that can be used to carefully select and evaluate the candidate specifications. Additionally, fostering a culture of adherence to standards and best practices is essential to ensure that all stakeholders understand and commit to the principle. Training and capacity-building initiatives should be implemented to equip staff with the knowledge and skills needed to apply standards effectively."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:obligation ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:obligation ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:common ;
    elap:rationale "Implementing the principle of using standards in the design and implementation of solutions is crucial for ensuring consistency, reliability, and interoperability across digital public services. Standards provide clear benchmarks and guidelines that help streamline development processes, reduce complexity, and enhance the quality of services. By adhering to established standards, organisations can ensure that their solutions are interoperable with other systems or services, facilitating seamless data exchange and integration. This approach also promotes transparency and accountability, as standards are often developed through consensus and reflect best practices. The Interoperable Europe Act underscores the importance of using harmonised standards to support the development of interoperable public services, contributing to government efficiency and reducing administrative burdens and costs for citizens and businesses. Compliance with these standards, while generally voluntary, provides a presumption of conformity with essential requirements, enhancing trust and reliability. Ultimately, the use of standards supports the creation of robust, scalable, and user-friendly public services that meet the needs of citizens and businesses."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "The Use of standards for the design and implementation of digital public services is key to ensure robust, efficient and interoperable solutions, fostering collaboration across organisations and quality in the delivery."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/903/oj> ;
    dct:title "Use of standards"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

elap:user-centricity a elap:Principle ;
    elap:aboutSource "The European Interoperability Framework is part of the Communication (COM(2017)134) from the European Commission adopted on 23 March 2017. The framework gives specific guidance on how to set up interoperable digital public services."@en ;
    elap:category category:governance ;
    elap:implications "Digital public services should be designed on the basis of identified user needs and should minimise the effort required from users to complete interactions with public administrations. Users should only be requested to provide information that is necessary for the service and, where legally and technically possible, should not be required to provide information already available to public administrations. Services should hide unnecessary administrative and organisational complexity, particularly where several public bodies collaborate in service delivery. Appropriate channels and, where relevant, single points of contact should facilitate access to services. User feedback should be systematically collected and considered when designing new services and improving existing ones. Solutions should also provide users with appropriate transparency and control concerning the use and reuse of their information, in accordance with applicable requirements."@en ;
    elap:influenceInDPSAttribute influence:desire ;
    elap:influenceInDPSLifecycle influence:desire ;
    elap:paGovernance pagovernance:nws ;
    elap:rationale "Users' needs and requirements should guide the design and delivery of digital public services. Users may include citizens, businesses, public administrations and other organisations accessing or benefiting from these services. Public services should minimise unnecessary interactions, administrative burden and exposure to the internal complexity of public administrations. In line with the once-only approach, users should not be repeatedly requested to provide information that public administrations already possess and can lawfully reuse. User-centric services should therefore provide simple and coherent interactions, appropriate access channels and opportunities for users to contribute feedback to the design and improvement of services."@en ;
    elap:relatedContent contenttype:legal-functional,
        contenttype:legal-governance,
        contenttype:organisational-functional,
        contenttype:organisational-governance,
        contenttype:semantic-functional,
        contenttype:semantic-governance,
        contenttype:technical-application-functional,
        contenttype:technical-governance,
        contenttype:technical-infrastructure-functional ;
    elap:statement "Digital public services are designed around users and their needs, minimising the effort and administrative burden required to access and use them."@en ;
    eira:scope "Business agnostic"@en ;
    dct:source <https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/user-centricity> ;
    dct:title "User-centricity"@en ;
    dcat:theme ioplayer:legal,
        ioplayer:organisational,
        ioplayer:semantic,
        ioplayer:technical .

<http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/903/oj> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Regulation (EU) 2024/903 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 March 2024 laying down measures for a high level of public sector interoperability across the Union (Interoperable Europe Act)"@en .

<https://bridge-smart-grid-storage-systems-digital-projects.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/bridge-reports/guidelines%20for%20implementing%20the%20prescribed%20technology-MJ0322251ENN.pdf> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Guidelines for implementing Scalability and Replicability Assessment (SRA) methodology"@en .

<https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/trust> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Digital trust, from Shaping Europe’s digital future"@en .

<https://ec.europa.eu/digital-building-blocks/sites/display/DIGITAL/What+is+eID> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "eID Building Block of DIGITAL Europe"@en .

<https://ec.europa.eu/newsroom/cipr/items/806197/> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Digital Resilience of Public Administration in EU"@en .

<https://ecas.org/digital-democracy/> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Digital Democracy of European Citizen Action Service (ECAS)"@en .

<https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A52017DC0134> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "COM(2017) 134 final ANNEX 2 COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE REGIONS European Interoperability Framework - Implementation Strategy"@en .

<https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32024R0903> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Regulation (EU) 2024/903 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 March 2024 laying down measures for a high level of public sector interoperability across the Union (Interoperable Europe Act)"@en .

<https://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri=cellar:2c2f2554-0faf-11e7-8a35-01aa75ed71a1.0017.02/DOC_1&format=PDF> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Technological neutrality and data portability Underlying Principle (5) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri=cellar:2c2f2554-0faf-11e7-8a35-01aa75ed71a1.0017.02/DOC_3&format=PDF> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "COM(2017) 134 final ANNEX 2 COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE REGIONS European Interoperability Framework - Implementation Strategy"@en .

<https://hubbardresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Decisions-Under-Uncertainty-23-July-2020-PDF.pdf> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Hubbard Decision Research"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Interoperable Europe Portal"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Transparency Underlying Principle (3) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.12> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Preservation of information Underlying Principle (11) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.3> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Openness Underlying Principle (2) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/administrative-simplification> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Administrative Simplification Underlying Principle (10) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/assessment-effectiveness-and-efficiency> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Assessment of Effectiveness and Efficiency Underlying Principle (12) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/business-continuity-plan> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "European Interoperability Framework"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/multilingualism> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Multilingualism Underlying Principle (9) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/reusability> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Reusability Underlying Principle (4) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/technological-neutrality-and-data-portability> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Technological neutrality and data portability Underlying Principle (5) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/glossary/term/user-centricity> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "User-Centricity Underlying Principle (6) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4842-4398-5_9> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "The Pillars of Composability"@en .

<https://openlibrary.org/books/OL37329774M/Solutions_Architect%27s_Handbook_-_Second_Edition> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Shrivastava, S., & Srivastav, N. (2020). Solutions Architect's Handbook. Packt Publishing. And the Public Procurement Directive (Directive 2014/24/EU)."@en .

<https://web.archive.org/web/20160819141303/http://opengroup.org/soa/source-book/soa/soa.htm> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Open Group"@en .

<https://www.eitdigital.eu/fileadmin/files/2020/publications/data-sovereignty/EIT-Digital-Data-Sovereignty-Summary-Report.pdf> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "European Digital Infrastructure and Data Sovereignty - A policy perspective"@en .

<https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/society/20210128STO96607/how-the-eu-wants-to-achieve-a-circular-economy-by-2050> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "How the EU wants to achieve a circular economy by 2050 in News European Parliament"@en .

<https://www.go-fair.org/fair-principles/> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "FAIR Principles"@en .

<https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/towards-a-framework-for-identifying-and-measuring-the-benefits-of-accessibility_9c674d70-en.html> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Towards a Framework for Identifying and Measuring the Benefits of Accessibility"@en .

<https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/speech/en/49379> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "European Ombudsman"@en .

<https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780080362366500084> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Applying the principle of separation of concerns in software development"@en .

<https://commission.europa.eu/publications/european-commission-digital-strategy_en> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "C(2022) 4388 final COMMUNICATION TO THE COMMISSION European Commission digital strategy Next generation digital Commission"@en .

<https://design-principles-for-data-spaces.org/> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Design Principles for Data Spaces Position Paper"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/european-interoperability-reference-architecture-eira/solution/eira> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "European Interoperability Reference Architecture (EIRA)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.2> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Subsidiarity and proportionality Underlying Principle (1) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://interoperable-europe.ec.europa.eu/collection/nifo-national-interoperability-framework-observatory/2-underlying-principles-european-public-services#2.4> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Security and Privacy Underlying Principle (8) of the European Interoperability Framework (EIF)"@en .

<https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/designing-and-delivering-public-services-in-the-digital-age_e056ef99-en.html> a dct:BibliographicResource ;
    dct:title "Designing and Delivering Public Services in the Digital Age"@en .

